DAWN
E-Paper | July 13, 2025
An Islamabad district and sessionscourt on Saturday suspended a lower court’s order to block 27 YouTube channels to the effect of five more channels, a day after a similar halt on channels of two journalists.
It emerged on Tuesday that an Islamabad court had ordered YouTube last month to block 27 channels for disseminating “fake, misleading, and defamatory” content against the government and armed forces. The sanctioned accounts were being run by journalists, political commentators and social media influencers in Pakistan and overseas.
On Friday, an Islamabad district and sessions court admitted two revision petitions — submitted by journalists Matiuallah Jan and Asad Ali Toor — against the judicial magistrate’s order blocking 27 YouTube channels, suspending the ban for the two petitioners. Additional District and Sessions Judge (ADSJ) Muhammad Afzal Majoka heard the two revision appeals and ordered the suspension in a one-page written order for each petition.
Six more of those affected had appealed against the lower court’s order today. ADSJ Majoka heard the case and granted similar relief to the following five individuals: Makhdoom Shahabuddin, Orya Maqbool Jan, Abdul Qadir, Uzair Anwar and Umair Rafique.
The court adjourned proceedings on Habib Akram’s application till July 14 due to the unavailability of the petitioner. As per the short orders, seen by Dawn.com, the petitioners contended that they were not even given a prior notice and that the ban violated Article 10-A of the Constitution. The judge agreed that no notices were issued to the petitioners before the blocking order was passed and the point needed further consideration.
The ban order sparked criticism from various legal and digital rights groups.
On Wednesday, Minister of State for Interior Talal Chaudhry said that the owners of these channels would face criminal action.
The Forum for Digital Rights and Democracy (FDRD) and the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) on Wednesday condemned the decision, calling it a “blatant violation” of fundamental rights and an assault on press freedom.
The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP) has also expressed concern over the ban, stating, “The wholesale blocking of entire channels — rather than addressing specific instances of unlawful or hateful speech in accordance with due process — conflates dissent with criminal activity.”
“The constitutional right to freedom of expression is fundamental not only for individual liberty but also for ensuring government accountability, fostering debate and enabling the public to access a diversity of viewpoints,” the HRCP said, urging “precise and proportionate” interventions against hate speech.
On March 20, Farhan Mallick, the founder of media agency Raftar and a former news director at Samaa TV, was arrested in Karachi and booked under Peca as well as the Pakistan Penal Code in a case related to alleged anti-state content on his YouTube channel.
The arrest was met with widespread criticism from media bodies as well as rights activists.
He was granted bail in April in the many cases against him pertaining to allegedly “anti-state” content and data theft through a call centre.
In May, Pakistan Telecommunication Authority lifted the ban on X after the platform was inaccessible to users for more than a year. The social media platform was blocked in February 2024, around 10 days after the general elections, while the caretaker government was still in power.
Pakistan
0
Read more
Islamabad court orders blocking of 27 YouTube channels on NCCIA’s request
HRCP expresses concern as govt warns criminal action against 27 YouTube channels set for blocking
Islamabad court suspends order banning YouTube channels of Matiullah Jan, Asad Toor
On DawnNews
حمیرا اصغر کی موت: شوبز میں تنہائی اور ذہنی دباؤ کی کہانی!
‘سلگتے بلوچستان کی آگ ماضی میں دھیمی تو ضرور ہوئی لیکن کبھی بجھی نہیں’
‘گڈ مسلم، بیڈ مسلم’ اور زہران ممدانی کا نیویارک
Dawn News English
EXPLAINED: What Black Boxes Reveal After A Plane Crash
Gaza Ceasefire
Pakistan’s Street Vendors: Who Runs The Cities?
Trump Targeting Brazil: Why South Asia Should Pay Attention
Human Rights Vs Securing Borders: US And Pakistan’s Immigration Policy
Russia Recognises Afghan Taliban Govt In Afghanistan: What’s Next?
Why Education Can Fix Pakistan
EXPLAINED: What Black Boxes Reveal After A Plane Crash
Gaza Ceasefire
Pakistan’s Street Vendors: Who Runs The Cities?
Trump Targeting Brazil: Why South Asia Should Pay Attention
Human Rights Vs Securing Borders: US And Pakistan’s Immigration Policy
Russia Recognises Afghan Taliban Govt In Afghanistan: What’s Next?
Why Education Can Fix Pakistan
EXPLAINED: What Black Boxes Reveal After A Plane Crash
Latest Stories
One killed, 2 others injured in explosion in KP’s Lakki Marwat: police
Enrollment in non-formal education sector increases by 20pc: report
5 PTI MNAs expelled from party for voting in favour of 26th Amendment
PSB seeks clarification from PNF on ‘first position’ in Asian Youth Netball Championship
Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar to travel to China for SCO meeting tomorrow
Pakistan’s Hockey U-18 Asia Cup dream comes to an end as Japan wins final 3-0
dawn images site
‘Actors, not beggars’: Syed Mohammed Ahmed joins growing chorus against payment delays in showbiz
If you’re looking for something different in Karachi, K Pav’s new restaurant is the place for you
Durefishan Saleem prays death doesn’t come to anyone in silence, loneliness, or an empty room
Most Popular
01
MQM founder Altaf Hussain hospitalised in London after ‘severe illness’
02
Why did they flatten Gaza?
03
Brother of actor Humaira Asghar denies media reports on family refusing to claim body
04
UAE assures full visa facilitation support for Pakistanis
05
Gruesome murders
06
JUI-F chief Fazl advises ‘change’ in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa administration
07
Punjab govt to give Rs350bn for railway track upgrade
08
Pakistan, Russia sign agreement to revive Pakistan Steel Mills, reaffirm ‘long-standing industrial partnership’
09
Foreign Office slams Ajit Doval over ‘successful hits’ claims
Must Read
Editorial: It is painful to see civilian leaders scrambling to assert their relevancy
Once elected office is reduced to theatre, useful only for maintaining appearances, it becomes a stage for managing perceptions rather than exercising power.
Smokers’ corner: Decoding party politics
A new Pakistan
Muhammad Amir Rana
Hot and stressed in Karachi
Rewriting the past: Indonesia’s new history books spook scholars
AFP
Opinion
A new Pakistan
Muhammad Amir Rana
The current geopolitical environment is shifting in Pakistan’s favour.
Updated 13 Jul, 2025
Travel well, my friend Zubeida
Abbas Nasir
13 Jul, 2025
Parallel wars
Fahd Humayun
13 Jul, 2025
Another rat race
Muna Khan
Updated 12 Jul, 2025
Why did they flatten Gaza?
Pervez Hoodbhoy
Editorial
Updated 13 Jul, 2025
Hybrid worries
Once elected office is reduced to theatre, useful only for maintaining appearances, it becomes a stage for managing perceptions rather than exercising power.
13 Jul, 2025
Bitter taste
THE government’s plan to import 350,000 tonnes of sugar, months after allowing the export of more than twice that...
13 Jul, 2025
No red lines
THE US’ move to sanction Francesca Albanese, the UN’s Special Rapporteur on human rights in the occupied...
Updated 12 Jul, 2025
Gruesome murders
Long-term security can only be achieved when there is equitable development across Balochistan.
12 Jul, 2025
Solar policy
SOLAR net metering reforms are back in the limelight. On Thursday, Power Minister Awais Leghari announced that he...
12 Jul, 2025
New hope
EDUCATION shapes the destiny of a nation. Sadly, Pakistan’s public education sector is experiencing a national...
DAWN.COM Logo
Whatsapp
Twitter
Facebook
Instagram
Apple
Android
Huwaei App Gallery
Contact Contribution Guidelines Code of Ethics AI Policy Terms of Use Privacy Comment Moderation
Subscribe to Newspaper Reproduction Copyrights Advertise on Dawn.com Branded Content Careers Obituaries
Prayer Timings Stock/Forex/Gold Weather
Dawn Prism Images Special Reports Aurora Dawn News
Eos/Icon/Young World Cityfm89 Herald Teeli
Copyright © 2025, Dawn
NewsKit Publishing Platform
by Compunode
Comments
Post a Comment